Justin Bieber’s Twitch Song Has Everyone Reopening The Selena vs. Hailey Debate

A resurfaced Bieber stream sparks chaos: who is he singing about?
BY
Chief Editor & Celebrity Expert
justin bieber twitch song

Soo, Justin Bieber is getting emotional over heartbreak, and just like you, Pop Tellers, my mind is frazzled.

A resurfaced Twitch stream from October 27 shows him crying in a dim recording studio while singing about a relationship he couldn’t let go of. Picture it: Justin clutching his mic, mood-setting lighting, full band behind him… and he starts letting every emotion spill out.

He opens with raw lyrics: “My heart can’t take it / My bones can’t take it / I just can’t shake it, no / My bedroom’s aching and I’m lost without you / My lungs are breathing for you.”

Yep. Deep.

Justin Sings About Relationship Struggles

As the stream continued, Justin kept unpacking this messy, complicated relationship. He describes his lover as his “perfect puzzle piece,” someone he clearly couldn’t detach from.

“If I’m where I’m supposed to be / But I keep on questioning you,” he sings, getting even more vulnerable. Then he spirals into self-awareness: “So prone of getting tired / So prone of getting angry / I’m predisposed to this / I need you close to me.”

He pauses mid-song to make a statement that hits different: “all of this hard can never go to waste.”

It’s giving love hurts but I’m still here energy.

Bieber’s Song Hints At a Breakup

Justin then goes full existential breakup mode with lines that sound like every late-night text you didn’t send: “Do I exist to love you? / We want to call it quits / Is it too late for you to trust me? / Is it just a game and do I seem insane?”

Then the question that literally haunts every toxic situationship: “Why don’t I leave? / Why do I stay? / When do we change? / How can I stay loving you?”

Let me tell you, the man was fighting demons live on Twitch.

But Then—Plot Twist: Hope?

Just when you think he’s emotionally tapped out, Justin flips the tone. Suddenly the relationship is magical again, like the heartbreak never happened:

“You’re making my dreams come true / Baby, baby, what would I do without you? / My heart would turn to stone / If all of this would go away, what would I do without you?”

It goes from crying on the floor to “you’re my soulmate” in seconds. Explain this to me like I’m five, Mr. Bieber.

Hailey or Selena? Fans Are Going Full FBI

The clip resurfaced on TikTok and X over the weekend, and obviously fans are losing it. It wouldn’t be a Justin Bieber song without theories flying everywhere, raising the question: Is this about Selena?

Some think the lyrics hit way too close to his past relationship with Selena Gomez, especially since he mentions a relationship from when he was 18 (“like when we were 18”). He also sings, “‘I’m stuck in a relationship that is not you’”…so yeah, you can understand why some fans are spiraling.

Others insist it has to be about his wife, Hailey Bieber, considering the ups and downs they’ve rumored to have since tying the knot. Aka, Hailey showing up “ringless” to events and Justin’s offbeat vibes in pap shots.

Even though the power couple keeps shutting down split rumors, Justin has openly confessed to marriage struggles before, including in his Swag album. So yeah… fans are connecting dots.

Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
Share
Email
  • angela stephanou

    Angela is the Founder and Chief Editor of Pop Tales. With over a decade in writing, editing, and reporting on celebrities and pop culture, she oversees all content across the site. Angela covers it all, from breaking news and dating drama to celeb beauty and the best in movies and TV.

    Chief Editor & Celebrity Expert
Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments